Separate the wish from the commitment
Save the excursion you would enjoy, then label it optional until the operator confirms conditions and availability. Keep a version of the day that works without it. This approach does not predict cancellations; it reduces the consequences if plans change.
Do not chain assumptions
A boat arrival, transfer and international departure form separate commitments. Check each leg and its conditions. A line drawn on a map cannot confirm a timetable, and a short distance cannot guarantee a short journey.
Give the open day a purpose
Use it for the simplest version of the stay you wanted: a meal, time by the water or rest. If nothing changes, the buffer is still a holiday day. If a connection changes, it gives you choices.
Where a Thailand island buffer day belongs
A Thailand island buffer day is most useful beside a commitment you cannot easily change. Look at your final onward journey first, then work backwards through the boat, road transfer and check-in tasks. Keep room between separate bookings. This is a planning preference rather than a prediction about any particular operator or route.
Make the spare day enjoyable
Choose a simple local activity that does not depend on another complicated connection. A relaxed meal, time near your base or an optional short outing can make the buffer feel like part of the holiday. Keep the important documents and supplier contacts available. If every leg works as planned, you still have a day worth enjoying.